"For over 20 years I have presided over or participated as a panelist in hundreds of arbitrations. Those experiences have shown me the good, the bad and the ugly. Quite frankly, there are many more seriously egregious mistakes I have seen lawyers make; it was difficult to pare this list down to 10." Author Phil Cutler of Cutler Nylander & Hayton PS
#10 – Play Games: Engage in Cheap Games and Discovery Abuse; Continue Gamesmanship During the Hearing
#9 – Display Anger, Animosity and Rudeness: Personalize Everything; Engage in Ad Hominem Attacks
#8 – Overuse or Misuse Technology: Use Fancy but Unnecessary Technological or Demonstrative Aids; Fail to Know how to use Them
#7 – Waste Opportunities to Persuade the Arbitrator: Assume the Arbitrator Shares Your Knowledge of the Case; Fail to Analyze, Distill and Organize Your Case; File Long and Unpersuasive Briefs
#6 – Ask Inappropriate Questions; Fail to Pick up on an Opportunity to Deal With Something the Arbitrator views as Important; Ignore a Witness’s Non-Responsive Answer: Ask Questions That are not Really Questions or ask Overly Legalistic Questions of a Lay Witness; Rebuff Questions from the Arbitrator
#5 – Assume the Evidentiary Rules in Arbitration are the Same as Those in Court: Fail to Take the Time to Understand the Rules of Evidence; Make Numerous and Ineffective Evidentiary Objections
#4 – Misuse Cross-Examination of Witnesses: Try and use Cross to Prove Your Case in Chief; Fail to Plan Cross Before the Hearing
#3 – Continue Blithely on, Ignoring What Common Sense Tells (or Should Tell) You: Fail to Know When to Stop; Treat the Arbitrator as an Unsophisticated Rube
#2 – Make it Difficult for the Arbitrator to Rule in Your Client’s Favor: Fail to Organize Your Case and get Your Client’s Story Across
#1 – Fail to Tell the Arbitrator Exactly What Your Client Wants: Don’t Tell her, Keep it a Secret; Hope the Arbitrator “gets it” by Osmosis
Read Full Story►